Virginia Supreme Court affirms custody case ruling favoring lesbian mother

The Virginia Supreme Court affirmed a prior ruling by the Virginia Court of Appeals that said that the state must honor the Vermont Supreme Court’s order of visitation between Janet Jenkins and her daughter.

Janet Jenkins (formerly Miller-Jenkins) and Lisa Miller (formerly Miller-Jenkins) were joined in a civil union in Vermont and thereafter had a child. After the women ended their relationship, Miller moved to Virginia with the women’s daughter, and asked a Vermont court to dissolve the couple’s civil union and sort out custody of the child. When the Vermont court ordered visitation for Jenkins, Miller filed a new lawsuit in a Virginia court, using that state’s antigay marriage law to have herself declared the child’s sole legal parent.

The conflicting court orders – one from Vermont ordering regular visitation for Jenkins, and the other from a lower court in Virginia naming Miller as the sole parent – led to a decision by the Virginia Court of Appeals that the lower court in Virginia was wrong to contradict the Vermont court order granting Janet Jenkins visitation rights. A few months later, the Virginia Court of Appeals, based on its earlier decision, reiterated that Virginia must enforce the Vermont court order. Lisa Miller appealed that decision to the Virginia Supreme Court resulting in today’s decision.

“I’m relieved that this tug of war with my daughter is over,” said Janet Jenkins. “This has been a very long four years. My daughter and I need some time to be together – she needs her other mom.”

Jenkins’ legal team argued that the federal Parental Kidnapping Prevention Act and Virginia’s Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act make it clear that the Vermont court alone has jurisdiction in the matter and cannot be interfered with. Furthermore, the federal kidnapping law (PKPA) requires that the Vermont order be enforced in Virginia.

Greg Nevins, Senior Staff Attorney in Lambda Legal’s Southern Regional Office in Atlanta is handling the case along with co-counsel Rebecca Glendberg of the ACLU of Virginia and Joseph Price of the law firm Arent Fox LLP who argued the case on behalf of Jenkins.

Article adapted by from original press release.

One thought on “Virginia Supreme Court affirms custody case ruling favoring lesbian mother

  • December 6, 2009 at 4:05 pm

    You talk about lies from the so-called Christian Right, but you yourself are publishig a deceptive article. Unlike nearly every other story about this situation you fail to note that a) the biological mother is Miller. It is not biologically possible for Jenkins to be the other parent. They became “parents” because MIller was artificially inseminated. Jenkins never adopted the child. While you are accusIng Miller of selfish bigotry, how about Jenkins? She was given The opportunity for supervised visitation and refused to exercise it. If one of my children was away from me and the only way I could see that child was supervised visitation I would do it, just to be able to see the child. So who is being selfish. If she can’t have her way, Jenkins will Tear the child away from her biological mother with whom the child has lived all of her life. Allegations of inappropriate behavIor have been made and found false by the court because the only witness is a child. You also fail to note Jenkins many vicious anti-Christian statements and accusations. But, of course, to you, that isn’t bigotry, its fact. Attending a Christian Church is apparently now a ground for removing a child from a home. So talking about bias– how about looking at all the facts of a case. What if it were a lesbian mother and an abusive father who wanted to take a child away to teach the mother a lesson?
    Then what would you think?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.